CENSE Book a free facility review
All projects

Why operators were too hot in a 19 °C room

  • HVAC systems
  • Cleanroom infrastructure
  • EN 16798-1
  • Thermal stress
An operator in a protective suit and hairnet walking down a stainless steel stair
A spray dryer in a cleanroom, with stainless steel piping and a ceiling air diffuser
On site: a suited operator in the production area, and a spray dryer.

The challenge

Operators in a production plant kept reporting that their compartments were too hot, even though the rooms were running at their design conditions.

What we did

We reviewed the as-built documentation, analysed trend data from winter and summer, calculated how much sensible heat the ventilation removes from each room, and ran a comfort simulation to EN 16798-1.

What we found

The rooms were not too warm, at 19 to 21 °C. The operators were. A vapour-tight protective suit combined with heavy work puts them outside the comfort range, even at 19 °C and 50 % RH.

Predicted share of dissatisfied operators (PPD)

18 %at 19 °C

up to 28 %at 21 °C, still within specification

Each dot is one suited operator. Red: predicted to be dissatisfied at 19 °C (predicted mean vote +0.79). Light red: the extra share at 21 °C, a room temperature that is still within specification. EN 16798-1 aims for 10 % or less.

The result

Within the limits of the existing installation, we proposed how to lower the temperature in the production area so operators can work more comfortably. We started with measures of limited impact, such as adjusted supply setpoints, and added physical adaptations to reach the best possible result.

Next projectA phase-out roadmap for 689 cooling installations